CollectionDX Network

Gotengo 2005

Comments

10 comments posted
Even though this has no

Even though this has no gimmicks, it's pretty cool. If I found one for $10-$20, I'd buy it, too.
You're totally NOT expecting too much for the price. In fact, the drill should be metal. I think we have gotten too used to getting bad toys for our money, and are too tolerant of spending $30 or more for toys that are essentially broken from the factory. We should expect something better than a faulty Rei Revoltech, for example, for the $25 or more that it cost. Of course, the only way to get the companies to make them better is to STOP buying them when we know they are of crappy quality. Then, companies may realize that they need to make a toy that has gimmicks, doesn't break when you use it the way it is supposed to be used (as a toy), and has some sort of quality control so it isn't broken in the box. There are toys I wanted, (Rei Revoltech 001, SOC GX-01 Mazinger) but knowing they fall apart when touched, or have gimmicks that look bad or don't work, decide they are NOT worth anything, much less the prices these companies charge for their faulty merchandise. I have a couple damaged SOCs and Revoltechs that no one would pay much for, but they're not much different from the ones that were faulty out of the box that I paid full price for.

seraph2011's picture
Posted by seraph2011 on 1 May, 2009 - 11:23
^^ What he said! ^^ Now, if

^^ What he said! ^^

Now, if you want a real Gotengo, check this out!

--
Sanjeev

Sanjeev's picture
Posted by Sanjeev on 1 May, 2009 - 12:09
Man forget all that it's

Man forget all that it's cool just because there isn't enough Yoji Shinkawa mecha merchandise out there.

Nidaram's picture
Posted by Nidaram on 1 May, 2009 - 14:58
Isn't this one of the faulty toys we're complaining about?

I held off on this because it was being promoted as a "collectible" although your review makes it look like a decent enough adversary for any one of my hundreds of Bandai Kaiju (yes, some of us do love those junky bastards. Kidnicky, you are not alone)I've seen Gotengo on clearance all over the place, so I guess I better jump soon.

And as far as junky toys go, at least Bandai vinyl is sturdy enough for the sand box, and that is what vinyl kaiju is all about. I know you all saw those bullmarks in Saturday afternoon broadcasts of "Godzilla vs. The Smog Monster" US kids were so deprived! On the other hand, Microman is dead due to QC issues, and their price point was always quite reasonable. If mass produced toys intended for kids don't hold up anymore, you better believe I'm going to be cautious around a so-called "toy" intended for a collector. After all, if it's marketed as a collectible, it will never be considered a collectible. Star Trek 101, ya'll.

Materialist Zen's picture
Posted by Materialist Zen on 1 May, 2009 - 15:16
Oh man, those Bullmarks that

Oh man, those Bullmarks that kid was playing with in that early scene in Godzilla vs. The Smog Monster have haunted me my whole life! Of course, NOW, I have glowie reissues of most of those guys, so I'm good!

Hehe...it's funny how much of a grey area toy collecting can be. I totally hear you about Bandai vinyls being good 'nuff because they can stand up to sandbox abuse. I appreciate that. Really!

But while I'm usually the *last* to defend "adult collectibles", I still prefer the size/quality from an M1, Marusan, or Marmit. It's those guys making the classic (read: "Bullmark")-sculpted kaiju toys I love so much.

Same thing with that Aoshima Gotengo I reviewed. Totally high-end, modern "adult collectible" diecast...with the pricetag to match. Still, I think with the sheer quality on that, the quality of materials (and copious diecast), and cool electronic gimmicks, it justifies the price...at least for me.

Hmmm...does this mean I prefer junky robots and collectible monsters?? ;)

--
Sanjeev

Sanjeev's picture
Posted by Sanjeev on 3 May, 2009 - 02:51
Takatoku Macross vinyl

Have you seen those? Now that's cheap vinyl! Yet I love them so.

I like vinyl as a cheap toy, the best cheap toy. It's hard for me to distinguish between Bandai and M1 in terms of quality, since they're both essentially the cheapest way to produce a toy. Beyond design aesthetics and economics of scale, they're both produced in a similar manner, using similar materials, achieving a similar effect. They're both great.

There's a certain novelty in M1 and the rest that Bandai will never match. Likewise, Bandai's output possesses a certain credibility that a fifty dollar "toy" does not. I think vinyl is a terrific media for toys in general, and both types of manufacturers are doing right by it, in their own way.

If you can hand either one off to a kid, I'm down with it. No matter the price range, it should deliver like a proper toy. Vinyl could not be more "what you see is what you get" and that's what makes vinyl toys the best. Anyone who is disgruntled over their robot falling apart needs to simplify.

Materialist Zen's picture
Posted by Materialist Zen on 3 May, 2009 - 22:52
Agreed. Though I'd argue

Agreed. Though I'd argue that M1 and the like are higher physical quality than Bandai, I think that's moot and already been discussed before. I enjoyed your point that as long as you can hand it off to a kid and it won't be ruined in under 30 seconds, it's a "toy". I'm all about simplifying!

--
Sanjeev

Sanjeev's picture
Posted by Sanjeev on 4 May, 2009 - 15:45
yeah

It was cool, but I sold mine, just could not get into owning something so small, it is the size of a paper weight.

AJProDie-Cast's picture
Posted by AJProDie-Cast on 1 May, 2009 - 17:37
Happy

Thank you for the comments

@seraph: Actually I was quite happy with it. It just my main core of collection is Sentai robots where I can play with while Goutengo is like a display model. 10$ is great price although the original price is also quite reasonable in my book.

Berserk's picture
Posted by Berserk on 3 May, 2009 - 19:18
" Likewise, Bandai's output

" Likewise, Bandai's output possesses a certain credibility that a fifty dollar "toy" does not."

Hell yes.
I don't know if I mentioned this before,but you know those s****y Mattel Infinite Heroes that are out now? I have like 20 of those things.

kidnicky's picture
Posted by kidnicky on 6 May, 2009 - 14:46
 
CollectionDX OtakuDX Love is Pop WTF Toy Chogokin.net